Hello dear
Welcome to Goodfellas Pizza Amsterdam
Goodfellas Pizza Amsterdam, located at 1 Hewitt St, is a beloved pizza destination in Amsterdam, NY. Renowned for their quick service and friendly atmosphere, they promise an exceptional dining experience. Patrons rave about their fresh, customizable pizzas and delicious garlic knots, often described as a must-try. The large salads are generously portioned and refreshing, appealing to both pizza lovers and health-conscious diners alike. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Goodfellas has quickly become a local favorite, perfect for anyone seeking comfort food that feels like home. Whether you're dining in or taking out, it’s a spot worth visiting.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Goodfellas Pizza Amsterdam
Welcome to the delightful world of Goodfellas Pizza Amsterdam, where passion for quality and flavor takes center stage! Nestled in the heart of Amsterdam, NY, at 1 Hewitt St, this pizzeria quickly captures the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Known for its inviting atmosphere and warm, friendly service, Goodfellas Pizza has established itself as a beloved dining spot for pizza lovers.
As you step inside, the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizza greets you. Customers rave about the quick service and the staff's genuine helpfulness, making every visit a pleasant experience. Andrew Percetti shares, "Stopped in the other day... Ordered a pie and knots. Quick service and friendly customer service. Highly recommend." This enthusiasm reflects the welcoming environment cultivated by Goodfellas.
The menu boasts a variety of pizza options that cater to every craving. Whether you're in the mood for classic cheese slices or a more adventurous topping combination, Goodfellas will customize your order to perfection. Kallyne Agosto notes, "Our go-to for pizza. They will customize your order to your cravings," a testament to their commitment to customer satisfaction.
Not just your average pizza place, Goodfellas Pizza also shines with their delectable garlic knots and hearty salads. Denise Fiet recounts, "The house salad was big, with freshly chopped lettuce and delicious toppings... The knots were perfect." It's clear that each dish is crafted with care and using quality ingredients, ensuring a memorable meal every time.
With great food at affordable prices, new customers like Mustafa Choukeir quickly turn into regulars. "Our new go-to pizza spot. Great food. Great prices!!" It's no wonder that this charming pizzeria has become a cornerstone for the community.
In summary, if you're searching for a pizza experience that combines quality ingredients, friendly service, and an inviting atmosphere, look no further than Goodfellas Pizza Amsterdam. Whether you're stopping in for a quick slice or planning a meal for family and friends, this pizzeria promises to deliver satisfaction with every bite. Don't miss out on this delectable pizza haven!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Stopped in the other day on our way back home. Ordered a pie and knots. Quick service and friendly customer service. Highly recommend. ”
“ Everything was great! Super helpful staff, food was fresh and made at the moment! Will definitely be making it our number one pizza spot! ”
“ Our go to for pizza. They will customize your order to your cravings. ”
“ Just moved to the area a few months ago. Our new go to pizza spot. Great food. Great prices!! ”
“ Had dinner in the place last night. We always enjoy the pizza but this time decided to also get the garlic knots and a large salad. The house salad was big, with freshly chopped lettuce and delicious toppings. Enough for 3 hungry people. The knots were perfect. Now I want more thinking about them! Friendly service also. ”
“ Tried this place tonight for take out. Would highly recommend. The pizza was great. Not too thick. Sauce had good flavor and enough cheese on it . Very good ”
“ We order from there ,and that's the only place we get pizza from,the food is awesome ,the staff members are friendly,always in a good mood,the wings are the best we've ever had!!! ”
“ First time stopping after many years of driving past. Excellent White Pizza with tomatoes, Excellent Hawaiian Pizza, and Excellent Wings. Excellent crust on the pizzas. Will Definitely be a returning customer ”